A devil's advocate rejoinder to the theory of indigenous matriarchy
In my previous article, I discussed the book Matriarchal Societies by Heide Gottner-Abendroth and my generally positive (with a few qualifications) appraisal of this work. In the spirit of fairness, however, and given the highly speculative nature of any theory which back-projects onto a prehistoric past, I feel it is best to present the best "steel man" critique I can muster to the hypothesis of human's prehistoric matriarchal nature. This does not mean that I am personally "sold" on matriarchal prehistory being false, and in fact I think the Gottner-Abendroth version of this theory (as opposed to some older, highly essentialist versions of it) may well turn out to be accurate. I certainly believe it is a good deal more plausible than the standard evo-psych narrative of prehistoric, universal patriarchy in which men's paternity anxiety and 'natural' competitiveness ends up somehow creating stereotypical gender-linked behaviors (such as higher m